MA & Co AccountantsMA & Co Accountants

Dividend vs Salary in 2025: What's Best for Company Directors?

With significant changes to National Insurance rates in 2025, company directors need to reassess their optimal salary and dividend strategy. This comprehensive guide explains the current tax rules and helps you calculate the most tax-efficient profit extraction method for your limited company.

Key Changes for 2025-26

The 2025-26 tax year brings substantial changes that affect the optimal salary vs dividend balance:

Major Changes:

  • Employer National Insurance rate increased from 13.8% to 15%
  • Secondary threshold reduced from £9,100 to £5,000 annually
  • Employment Allowance increased from £5,000 to £10,500
  • Employment Allowance £100,000 restriction lifted
  • Dividend allowance remains at £500

Current Tax Rates and Thresholds

National Insurance Rates 2025-26

Category Rate Threshold
Employee NI (Primary) 8% (up to £50,270), then 2% £12,570 annually
Employer NI (Secondary) 15% £5,000 annually
Employment Allowance Up to £10,500 For eligible businesses

Dividend Tax Rates 2025-26

Tax Band Rate Income Range
Basic Rate 8.75% Up to £50,270
Higher Rate 33.75% £50,271 - £125,140
Additional Rate 39.35% Over £125,140

Corporation Tax Rates 2025

Profit Level Rate Notes
Up to £50,000 19% Small profits rate
£50,001 - £250,000 25% with marginal relief Tapered rate
Over £250,000 25% Main rate

Optimal Salary Strategies for 2025-26

Option 1: Sole Directors (No Employment Allowance)

For companies with sole directors and no other employees, the optimal salary is £5,000 annually (£417 per month).

Salary: £5,000 per year

  • Employee NI: £0 (below £12,570 threshold)
  • Employer NI: £0 (at the £5,000 threshold)
  • Income Tax: £0 (below personal allowance)
  • Corporation Tax relief: £950 (£5,000 × 19%)
  • Net cost to company: £4,050

Option 2: Companies with Employment Allowance

Companies with employees or multiple directors may benefit from the £12,570 salary strategy if they can claim Employment Allowance.

Salary: £12,570 per year

  • Employee NI: £0 (at threshold)
  • Employer NI: £1,135.50 (but offset by Employment Allowance)
  • Income Tax: £0 (at personal allowance)
  • Corporation Tax relief: £2,388 (£12,570 × 19%)
  • Net cost to company: £10,182

Worked Example: £100,000 Profit Extraction

Scenario A: Sole Director Strategy

Salary: £5,000 + Dividends: £95,000

Salary Costs:
  • Gross salary: £5,000
  • Employer NI: £0
  • Corporation tax relief: £950
  • Net salary received: £5,000
Dividend Calculation:
  • Available for dividends: £95,950 (after salary and corporation tax)
  • Corporation tax on remaining profit: £18,230 (£95,950 × 19%)
  • Available for distribution: £77,720
  • Dividend tax: £6,732 ((£77,720 - £500) × 8.75%)
  • Net dividend received: £70,988
Total:
  • Total received: £75,988
  • Total tax and NI: £24,962
  • Effective rate: 24.96%

Scenario B: Employment Allowance Strategy

Salary: £12,570 + Dividends: £87,430

Salary Costs:
  • Gross salary: £12,570
  • Employer NI: £1,136 (offset by Employment Allowance)
  • Corporation tax relief: £2,388
  • Net salary received: £12,570
Dividend Calculation:
  • Available for dividends: £89,818
  • Corporation tax: £17,065
  • Available for distribution: £72,753
  • Dividend tax: £6,322 ((£72,753 - £500) × 8.75%)
  • Net dividend received: £66,431
Total:
  • Total received: £79,001
  • Total tax and NI: £23,387
  • Effective rate: 23.39%

Common HMRC Traps to Avoid

⚠️ Key Compliance Issues:

  • IR35 Rules: Ensure genuine employment status if contracting through a limited company
  • Dividend Documentation: Proper board resolutions and dividend vouchers required
  • Sufficient Profits: Cannot declare dividends exceeding distributable reserves
  • Equal Treatment: Dividends must be paid proportionally to shareholdings
  • Employment Allowance Eligibility: Cannot claim if only director/family members employed

When Higher Salaries Make Sense

Consider a higher salary strategy if:

  • Pension contributions: Higher earnings increase annual allowance capacity
  • Mortgage applications: Lenders often prefer salary income over dividends
  • Maternity/paternity pay: Benefits based on salary levels
  • State pension entitlement: National Insurance credits protect future benefits
  • Childcare vouchers: Salary sacrifice schemes require employment income

Record Keeping Requirements

HMRC requires comprehensive documentation:

For Salaries:

  • Employment contracts and service agreements
  • Payroll records and RTI submissions
  • P60 and P11D forms
  • PAYE and National Insurance calculations

For Dividends:

  • Board meeting minutes authorising payments
  • Dividend vouchers with tax credits
  • Company accounts showing distributable reserves
  • Shareholder resolutions if required

When to Seek Professional Advice

Consider professional guidance if:

  • Company profits exceed £100,000 annually
  • Multiple shareholders with different tax positions
  • International tax implications
  • Complex group structures or associated companies
  • Significant pension or property investments
  • IR35 or employment status concerns

Need Help Optimising Your Salary and Dividend Strategy?

Our qualified accountants can calculate your optimal profit extraction strategy and ensure full HMRC compliance. Book a free consultation to discuss your specific circumstances.